Trump, Xi and Putin want a three-power world order
Presidents Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin met in Shenzhen on 19 November, for the first time as a trio, nine months after the New START nuclear treaty expired. They want to reform the United Nations, in a three-way commitment without France and the United Kingdom, the other two veto-holding permanent members of the Security Council.
The meeting lasted about an hour and a half and took place on the margins of the Asia-Pacific summit hosted by China. It produced a declaration "toward Peace", published by the Chinese government. It has four points: reform of the United Nations, dialogue on nuclear risk, more refined fuel and a warning to the International Criminal Court. It has no dates, no quantities and no follow-up meeting.
Reform of the United Nations is left undefined. The three take it on as permanent members of the Security Council, so that the organisation can respond more effectively to global challenges. They say nothing about enlarging the Council. The African Union demands at least two permanent seats, with the veto for as long as it exists, and five non-permanent ones. No African state was at the table, and by the afternoon of 19 November TorreNews had found no reaction to the meeting from the African Union.
The nuclear point comes without a treaty. New START capped the strategic arsenals of the United States and Russia and expired on 5 February. Since then there has been no legal limit on the arsenals of the two nuclear superpowers, according to Arms Control Today. Trump said it would be appropriate to include China in a new deal, but that he would do one with Russia without it, the same magazine reported. On 16 October, Beijing refused three-way disarmament talks, according to Time magazine. In Shenzhen, the three reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and promised dialogue on the risk. China accepted a sentence and a dialogue, and no numbers.
The war with Iran weighs on the energy point. The Strait of Hormuz closed on 28 February, and about a fifth of the world's liquefied natural gas used to pass through it, according to the United States Energy Information Administration. The three plan to increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products for the benefit of all nations. Trump said in Shenzhen that Xi agreed the strait must stay open, according to Al Jazeera. The declaration does not say so, nor does it name Iran.
The court point touches one of the three. Putin has been under an International Criminal Court arrest warrant since 17 March 2023. The declaration says that state consent and the immunities of state officials are of paramount importance, and that this court and similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction.
Artificial intelligence was left out. In September, Trump and Xi had agreed to set up an urgent communication channel for artificial intelligence incidents, according to Euronews. In Shenzhen, Trump rejected global rules and Xi called for the technology to stay under human control. The dispute between the two countries reaches business too. Jensen Huang, chief executive of Nvidia, the American maker of chips for artificial intelligence, was forced to resign over a scandal, according to Time. Huang said he had an affair with a woman accused of funnelling semiconductors to China. The magazine cites reports that American intelligence suspects her of being a spy, which China denies.
Each arrived in circumstances of his own. Putin proposed the meeting, according to John Herbst, who heads the Eurasia Center at the Atlantic Council, a Washington think tank. Trump travelled after November's midterm elections, which Time calls "chastening". The week before, the United States halted departures nationwide for more than four hours, a stoppage the American government attributes to the replacement of air traffic control network equipment, according to Al Jazeera. "So we don't believe this was cyber at all," said the transportation secretary, Sean Duffy. Xi is likely to secure a fourth term at the 2027 Communist Party congress, Melanie Hart, who heads the council's Global China Hub, wrote before the meeting. "China is looking for show, not substance," she wrote.
What ties these facts together is the absence of rules. The treaty capping the American and Russian arsenals has lapsed, there are no common rules for artificial intelligence, and the three warn the International Criminal Court. Trump faces difficulties at home, Putin an arrest warrant and Xi a congress to prepare. A joint photo may serve each of them. With no such rules in place, three of the five permanent members of the Security Council made the declaration, without the other two, on the United Nations, nuclear weapons, energy and the courts. It would be the outline of a three-power world order, in which these three decide first and the rest find out later.
Nothing guarantees the format will last. The Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov said it is too early to say whether it will be repeated, according to the Russian state agency TASS. Other Atlantic Council experts also expected, before the meeting, more optics than results. It may have been no more than a photo opportunity.
The next test is the summit of the G20, the group of the largest economies, in Miami in December. Trump has invited Putin, according to Al Jazeera.
Comments (0)